CALL NOW
☰
Concord · Northern California · Statewide case reviews

California Defective Medical Device Lawyer

A medical device was supposed to help you heal. If it failed, caused complications, or became the subject of a recall, you deserve answers about your health and your legal options. Scranton Law Firm can review what happened and the records needed to investigate.

Available 24/7 · English & Spanish · Free, confidential case review
50+ YearsServing injured clients since 1973
ConcordNorthern California roots
24/7Call when you need us
English & SpanishTalk with our team
Your first steps

Start with your health. Then protect the evidence.

A recall is not a diagnosis, and a complication does not automatically mean a device was defective. Symptoms can have many causes. Ask your treating clinician to assess new or worsening problems. For a medical emergency, call 911.

Do not stop prescribed breathing therapy or arrange removal of an implant based on a legal advertisement. Your clinician should guide treatment. Save your implant card, model and serial numbers, operative reports, recall notices, and a timeline of symptoms.

Sources: Hip injuries symptoms and follow-up · Philips risks and care advice

Medical device concerns

Metal-on-metal hip implants

What went wrong

Metal rubbing against metal can release particles and ions. In February 2016, the FDA published a final order requiring premarket approval applications for metal-on-metal total hip replacement devices; the filing requirement took effect in May 2016. This was a regulatory action, not a recall of every hip implant. Hip resurfacing devices are a separate category.

Possible injuries and complications

The FDA describes adverse reactions around the joint that may damage tissue, loosen the implant, or lead to device failure. Some patients need revision surgery. A blood metal-ion result alone does not establish a legal claim.

Signs to discuss with your clinician

New or worsening hip or groin pain, swelling, weakness, numbness, unusual clicking or grinding, or a change in walking ability warrant contact with your orthopaedic surgeon.

What to do next

Ask your surgeon which implant you received and what follow-up is appropriate. Keep implant labels, imaging and revision records. If revision is planned, ask your care team and counsel about preserving the removed components without delaying necessary treatment.

Sources: Hip FDA regulatory actions · Hip injuries symptoms and follow-up

Medical device concerns

Hernia mesh

What went wrong

One documented example is the Bard Composix Kugel X-Large Patch recall initiated December 22, 2005: the FDA record says the memory recoil ring could break and potentially cause bowel perforation or a chronic enteric fistula. That recall applied to specified products and lots, not all hernia mesh.

Possible injuries and complications

The FDA lists pain, infection, recurrence, adhesions, bowel obstruction, fistula and perforation among hernia-repair complications. Mesh can also migrate or shrink. Some complications can occur even without mesh and do not establish a defect by themselves.

Signs to discuss with your clinician

Persistent or worsening pain, a returning bulge, or concerns about infection or bowel function should be evaluated by your surgeon. Do not try to diagnose mesh failure from symptoms alone.

What to do next

Request your operative report and product or lot information. Discuss whether symptoms relate to the repair and whether imaging or further treatment is needed. Save records of any additional surgery and expenses.

Sources: Composix Kugel recall · Hernia mesh complications

Medical device concerns

Philips CPAP and BiPAP machines

What went wrong

In June 2021, Philips recalled certain ventilators, CPAP and BiPAP machines because their PE-PUR sound-abatement foam could break down. Foam particles or invisible chemicals could be inhaled or swallowed. On April 9, 2024, a federal court entered a consent decree addressing remediation and regulatory compliance.

Possible injuries and complications

The FDA identifies potential irritation, inflammatory responses, headaches, asthma, and toxic or cancer-causing effects from foam-related exposure. These are potential risks, not proof that a machine caused a particular illness or that every user will be harmed.

Signs to discuss with your clinician

Report new airway irritation, headaches, dizziness or other health changes to your clinician. You may see black particles in tubing or a mask, but not seeing particles does not rule out exposure.

What to do next

Talk with your health care provider about whether to continue therapy, change treatment, or use another device. Stopping can pose greater risks for some patients. Do not remove the foam or add a filter to a CPAP/BiPAP machine to solve this issue. Keep the serial number, recall registration, usage history and medical records. Ask about safe evidence preservation before returning a device; do not delay necessary care.

Sources: Philips June 2021 recall and April 9 2024 decree · Philips risks and care advice

Medical device concerns

Inferior vena cava (IVC) filters

What went wrong

In 2014, the FDA advised clinicians to consider removing retrievable filters when protection against blood clots was no longer needed. Its December 21, 2021 authorization of a laser-based removal device discussed the difficulty of removing embedded filters. A separate OPTEASE recall initiated September 27, 2013 involved an incorrect orientation arrow on a unit, not a recall of all IVC filters.

Possible injuries and complications

The OPTEASE recall record describes upside-down implantation requiring an additional retrieval procedure. Embedded filters can be difficult to retrieve. The FDA’s 2021 release also describes bleeding, vein injury and filter breakage as possible complications observed during laser-assisted removal, not as injury rates for all filter users.

Signs to discuss with your clinician

A filter may need follow-up even without obvious symptoms. Tell your clinician about new symptoms and ask whether the filter is still needed. Sudden chest pain, breathing difficulty or collapse needs emergency assessment; these symptoms do not identify the cause.

What to do next

Obtain your implant card, placement date, imaging and any attempted-removal records. Ask the treating specialist whether your filter is retrievable and what the risks of leaving it in place or removing it are. A lawyer should evaluate the specific model and history, rather than assume every filter is defective.

Sources: IVC FDA 2014 removal advice and 2021 authorization · Optease September 27 2013 labeling recall

Medical device concerns

Pacemakers and implantable defibrillators

What went wrong

The Assurity pacemaker recall initiated March 15, 2021 involved a manufacturing issue that could permit moisture ingress. Separately, St. Jude initiated an October 10, 2016 recall of certain ICD and CRT-D defibrillators because lithium clusters could short-circuit the battery and cause premature depletion. Only specified devices are affected.

Possible injuries and complications

The pacemaker record describes loss of pacing, shortened battery life and loss of communication. Defibrillator battery depletion can prevent needed therapy. The clinical consequences depend on the device and how much the patient depends on it.

Signs to discuss with your clinician

Contact your device clinic about unexpected battery or remote-monitoring alerts, communication failures or new symptoms. Fainting, severe chest pain or major breathing problems require urgent medical assessment, whether or not a recall applies.

What to do next

Have the device clinic check your model and serial number, monitoring data and recall status. Keep alerts, interrogation reports and replacement records. Do not assume a recall requires immediate replacement: the Assurity recall recommendations do not advise routine preventive generator replacement. Your cardiology team should make the individualized treatment decision.

Sources: Assurity pacemaker recall · Defibrillator October 10 2016 battery recall

Other implanted or external devices may also warrant review. Bring the exact device name, manufacturer and medical history so the team can assess the facts and whether the firm can help.

Legal framework

California medical device liability: the basics

Defect and causation matter

California product liability law recognizes manufacturing defects, design defects and inadequate warnings. Some strict-liability claims do not require proof of negligence, but a claimant still must establish the applicable elements, including a causal connection to injury.

Prescription implanted devices have important limits: California generally does not impose strict liability for design defects on their manufacturers. Manufacturing-defect, warning and negligence theories require separate analysis. Warning duties may run to the prescribing clinician, and federal law may preempt some device claims. A recall or FDA clearance does not resolve those questions.

Do not wait for a recall deadline

California Code of Civil Procedure § 335.1 generally provides two years for personal-injury actions. Under the discovery rule, accrual may be delayed until the person discovers, or reasonably should discover, the injury and its wrongful cause. Learning of a recall does not automatically restart the clock.

Accrual, tolling and exceptions are fact-specific; other claims may have different rules. Ask counsel to calculate your deadline promptly rather than relying on a general statement or waiting for treatment to end.

Sources: Official California CACI 2024: product liability and delayed discovery (archived edition) · California Courts: filing deadlines, CCP 335.1 and delayed discovery · Riegel v. Medtronic, 552 U.S. 312 (2008): medical-device preemption

How cases may proceed

An MDL is not the same as one shared lawsuit

Under 28 U.S.C. § 1407, related federal civil cases with common factual questions may be transferred for coordinated or consolidated pretrial proceedings. This is multidistrict litigation (MDL). It is not automatically a class action, and coordination does not eliminate the need to establish each person’s injury, causation and damages.

Your case may be handled individually, as part of an MDL, or in state-court proceedings depending on the facts and applicable rules. Existing litigation does not mean a new claim is timely or that compensation is guaranteed. No current MDL enrollment or settlement eligibility is promised here.

Sources: 28 USC 1407 transfer for coordinated pretrial proceedings

Prepare for the conversation

What a medical device case review needs

1

Identify the device

Gather the implant card, manufacturer, model, lot or serial number, supplier and dates of use or implantation.

2

Collect medical records

Save operative reports, imaging, device checks, diagnoses, treatment plans and any revision or removal records.

3

Build a timeline

Note when symptoms began, when you first suspected a device issue, and when you received any recall notice.

4

Preserve supporting evidence

Keep notices, correspondence, bills, work-loss records and photos. Ask about safe preservation before a return, disposal or destructive inspection. Do not delay medical care.

5

Discuss an individual review

Our Concord-based team can discuss the records, potential deadlines and whether further investigation or a referral is appropriate.

Scranton Law Firm

Meet the team behind your case review

Scranton Law Firm has served injured clients since 1973. Contact our Concord office for a free case review, available 24/7 in English and Spanish.

Your questions

Defective medical device lawyer FAQ

Do I need a recall to have a medical device claim?

Not necessarily. A claim depends on the device, applicable legal theory, injury and causation. A recall does not prove a device caused your injury, and the absence of a recall does not by itself rule out a claim.

Should I stop using my recalled CPAP or BiPAP machine?

Discuss the benefits and risks with your health care provider before changing therapy. The FDA explains that stopping a recalled device can pose greater risks for some patients. Do not remove the foam or add a filter to a CPAP or BiPAP machine to address the foam issue.

How long do I have to file in California?

California personal-injury actions generally have a two-year filing period under CCP § 335.1. The discovery rule, tolling and other exceptions can affect when time starts or runs. A recall does not automatically restart the deadline. Have an attorney calculate your individual deadline promptly.

Does a recalled implant have to be removed?

Not automatically. A recall can involve monitoring, correction or other action rather than surgery. Your treating specialist should assess your device and health, including the risks of keeping or removing it. Do not schedule removal based solely on a legal advertisement.

Is a medical device MDL a class action?

Not automatically. An MDL coordinates or consolidates related federal cases for pretrial proceedings. Each person still needs an individual evaluation of injury, causation, damages and deadlines. Being part of coordinated litigation does not guarantee compensation.

Can you review my case if I do not know the device model?

You can start with the records you have. An implant card, operative report, supplier record or device-clinic report may help identify the product. Preserve remaining evidence and explain any missing records during the free case review.

Reference desk

Sources and legal information

Sources checked November 9, 2026. Recall histories are examples, not a list of every affected product. FDA reports of potential risks do not establish individual causation. General information, not legal or medical advice. The facts and applicable law determine your options.


Questions about a medical device injury?

Tell us what happened. Start with a free, confidential case review and a conversation about your next steps.

Available 24/7 · English & Spanish

Attorney Advertising. Scranton Law Firm, 2450 Stanwell Dr, Concord, CA 94520. Responsible attorney: Christian Scranton, California State Bar #196959. Prior results do not guarantee a similar outcome. No outcome or compensation is promised. Do not change medical treatment based on this advertisement; consult your clinician.