We Don't Win, You Don't Pay

Wrongful Death Claim Launched Over San Jose Garbage Truck Fatality

Wrongful Death Lawsuit San Jose, CA

Family Files Wrongful Death Lawsuit Following Fatal Garbage Truck Incident in San Jose

In a tragic incident in San Jose, California, Silvino Eloy Garcia, a local resident, lost his life after being struck by a garbage truck during his morning walk. The wrongful death lawsuit that ensued has cast a spotlight on the responsibilities and accountability of corporate entities in maintaining public safety, particularly in urban areas. This blog post will delve into the circumstances surrounding Garcia’s death, the legal actions taken by his family, and the broader implications of such accidents in the context of personal injury law.

Case Overview

On the morning of January 22, Silvino Eloy Garcia was engaged in his routine exercise walk around his neighborhood in San Jose when a tragic pedestrian accident occurred. Garcia was crossing McKendrie Street when he was struck by a garbage truck operated by Greenwaste Recovery. The truck, according to lawsuit filings, rolled through a stop sign and failed to yield to Garcia who was within an unmarked crosswalk at the time. Despite the immediate aftermath and emergency responses, Garcia succumbed to his injuries four days later at Santa Clara Valley Medical Center.

The incident, captured by a neighbor’s Ring doorbell camera, shows the truck failing to stop at the stop sign, hitting Garcia from behind, knocking him to the ground, and tragically driving over his body. This footage has become a pivotal piece of evidence in the wrongful death lawsuit filed by Garcia’s family against Greenwaste Recovery. The lawsuit accuses the company of negligence in the operation, management, and maintenance of its garbage truck.

In response to the lawsuit, a spokesperson from Greenwaste Recovery extended deep sympathies to Garcia’s family but refrained from commenting further due to the ongoing litigation. The lawsuit seeks unspecified monetary compensation for funeral expenses, loss of income, medical bills, and loss of companionship, reflecting the profound impact of Garcia’s death on his family, who are longstanding residents of San Jose.

Key Aspects Of The Case

  1. Negligence: Central to the lawsuit is the claim of negligence on the part of Greenwaste Recovery. The family’s legal team argues that the garbage truck driver failed to adhere to basic traffic safety laws, specifically ignoring the stop sign. This breach of duty directly contributed to the fatal accident.

  2. Evidence from Surveillance: The video evidence from a neighborhood surveillance system provided clear and indisputable proof that the garbage truck did not stop at the stop sign. This footage is expected to play a significant role in the lawsuit, as it visually corroborates the eyewitness accounts and provides a factual basis for the negligence claims.

  3. Company Responsibility: The lawsuit also questions the broader corporate responsibilities of Greenwaste Recovery, emphasizing the need for adequate training and oversight of their employees. The legal argument suggests that the company did not enforce sufficient safety protocols or provide adequate training to its drivers on urban driving and pedestrian safety.

  4. Damages Sought: The Garcia family is seeking compensatory damages for a variety of losses. These include tangible losses like medical and funeral expenses and intangible losses such as emotional distress and loss of companionship. The claim for punitive damages might also arise, aiming to penalize the company for its negligence and deter future misconduct.

These components underscore the complexities involved in wrongful death lawsuits and the rigorous scrutiny required to establish liability and secure justice for the victims.


Legal Challenges and Considerations

Proving Negligence: One of the foremost challenges in this case is proving negligence beyond a reasonable doubt. The plaintiff must demonstrate that the garbage truck driver had a duty to stop at the stop sign and that failing to do so was a direct violation of this duty, leading to Garcia’s death. The burden of proof lies with the Garcia family’s legal team to establish that the driver’s actions were not only careless but directly caused the fatal incident.

Defensive Claims: Greenwaste Recovery might employ several defensive strategies, such as claiming that Garcia was at fault for not using a marked crosswalk or that he did not take adequate precautions while crossing the street. They might also argue that external factors, such as poor visibility, contributed to the accident, thus diluting their liability.

Impact of Video Evidence: The availability of video evidence from a doorbell camera significantly strengthens the Garcia family’s case by visually documenting the incident. However, the defense might challenge the angles, quality, or completeness of this footage, or contest its interpretation in the context of traffic laws and driver expectations.

Settlement versus Trial: Both parties might consider the advantages of a settlement to avoid a lengthy and costly trial. Settlement discussions could focus on compensating the Garcia family while allowing Greenwaste Recovery to mitigate bad publicity and potential punitive damages.

Regulatory and Safety Compliance: The case may also explore whether Greenwaste Recovery complied with local and federal safety regulations regarding vehicle operation and driver training. Non-compliance could add weight to the negligence claims and impact the company’s legal standing.

If you or someone you know has suffered a loss similar to that of the Garcia family, it is crucial to seek experienced legal representation immediately. Dealing with the aftermath of a tragic accident can be overwhelmingly distressing, but you do not have to face it alone. Our law firm specializes in wrongful death cases and is committed to ensuring that justice is served for your loved ones.

We understand the intricacies of personal injury law and are prepared to guide you through each step of the legal process with compassion and determination. Our wrongful death lawyers will work tirelessly to investigate the incident, establish liability, and secure the compensation that you and your family deserve. Contact us today for a confidential consultation and let us help you find the path to closure and financial security.


What is wrongful death, and how is it determined in a lawsuit? Wrongful death occurs when a person dies due to the negligence or misconduct of another party. In a lawsuit, it is determined by proving that the deceased’s death was caused directly by the defendant’s action or inaction, and that it resulted in measurable damages to the surviving family members.

Can I file a wrongful death lawsuit if my loved one was killed by a commercial vehicle? Yes, if your loved one was killed due to the negligence of a commercial vehicle operator, such as a garbage truck driver, you might have grounds for a wrongful death lawsuit. It’s essential to consult with a wrongful death lawyer who can assess the specifics of your case and guide you through the legal process.

What kind of compensation can I expect from a wrongful death claim? Compensation in wrongful death cases may include medical costs incurred before death, funeral and burial expenses, loss of income and benefits that the deceased would have earned, loss of companionship, and emotional distress suffered by the family members.

How long do I have to file a wrongful death lawsuit? The statute of limitations for filing a wrongful death lawsuit varies by state. Generally, you have one to three years from the date of the deceased’s death to file a claim, but it’s crucial to consult a lawyer as soon as possible to ensure your rights are protected.

What should I do if I think I have a wrongful death claim? If you suspect that your loved one’s death constitutes a wrongful death, contact a specialized wrongful death lawyer immediately. They can provide you with a thorough evaluation of your case, help gather necessary evidence, and represent your interests in court or settlement negotiations.


Free Case Review

Visit Our Main Office

Don’t navigate the aftermath of a wrongful death case alone. Let the Scranton Law Firm stand by your side. With over 50 years of experience as personal injury lawyers, we’ve helped thousands recover from their losses. If you or a loved one are affected by a wrongful death due to negligence or premises liability don’t hesitate to reach out to us. Secure your rights and seek the justice you deserve. Looking for the best wrongful death lawyers near me –Look no further than The Scranton Law Firm, your trusted ally in these challenging times. Call 800-707-0707 now.