CALL NOW
โ˜ฐ
Multi-Vehicle April 16, 2014, article enriched Monterey Park / Alhambra, Los Angeles County

14 People Hurt After Fire Trucks Crash Into Monterey Park Restaurant

Two emergency vehicles responding to the same house fire collided at Garfield and Emerson, sending a Monterey Park fire engine into Lu Dumpling House. Later reporting said CHP blamed unsafe driving by the Alhambra truck, no criminal charges were filed, and one pedestrian who lost a leg later reached a $15 million settlement.

Incident Summary

Type
Fire apparatus intersection collision with pedestrian and building impacts
Location
Garfield Avenue and Emerson Avenue, near Lu Dumpling House, Monterey Park
Date
April 16, 2014
Time
About 3:00 p.m.
Vehicles
Alhambra fire ladder truck and Monterey Park fire engine
Emergency Run
Both trucks were responding to a house fire in Monterey Park with lights and sirens activated
Injuries
15 injured in follow-up reporting: four pedestrians, five restaurant patrons, and six firefighters
Critical Injury
Pedestrian Kenneth Thai reportedly lost his right leg above the knee
Investigation
CHP later said the Alhambra truck entered against a red light without ensuring the intersection was safe
Charges
No criminal charges filed after the yearlong investigation
Claims
At least five early claims were filed; later reporting said 22 claims had been filed in each city, with one dropped
Settlement
Thai was later set to receive a $15 million settlement from the cities and their insurers

How the Crash Happened

Early reports said two fire trucks responding to the same emergency collided in Monterey Park and sent one engine into a Chinese restaurant. Follow-up reporting filled in the sequence. According to the Los Angeles Times and ABC7, the crash happened at about 3 p.m. on April 16, 2014, as an Alhambra fire ladder truck traveled south on Garfield Avenue and a Monterey Park fire engine traveled east on Emerson Avenue. Both were headed to a house fire and both had lights and sirens activated.

Investigators later said the Monterey Park engine had the green light. The Alhambra truck approached the intersection against a red signal at roughly 15 mph, while the Monterey Park engine was moving about 20 to 25 mph. CHP concluded the Alhambra driver failed to ensure the intersection was safe before entering. After impact, the Monterey Park engine continued forward, struck a pedestrian, hit a pole, and crashed into Lu Dumpling House.

That fuller timeline matters because it changed the story from a vague emergency-response crash into a documented intersection collision with identified fault findings, multiple categories of victims, and long-term consequences for people who were simply crossing the street or eating lunch.

What Follow-Up Reporting Revealed About the Injuries

Initial coverage focused on the shock of the engine plowing into the restaurant. Later reporting showed the injury count was broader than the first summaries suggested. The Los Angeles Times said 15 people were injured: five restaurant patrons, four pedestrians, and six firefighters. ABC7 similarly reported nine civilians were hurt.

The most severe injury was to Kenneth Thai, a Monterey Park pedestrian who was waiting to cross when the engine was pushed onto the sidewalk. Court-related reporting later said Thai was pinned under the truck and suffered catastrophic injuries, including the loss of his right leg above the knee, multiple fractures, facial nerve damage, double vision, and other lasting physical harm. By mid-2015, reported medical expenses alone exceeded $530,000.

Pasadena Star-News also reported claims from restaurant workers and diners alleging eye injuries, head trauma, spinal pain, emotional distress, and other orthopedic injuries. Lu Dumpling House itself was boarded up and undergoing repairs after the impact tore into the building.

Investigation, Claims, and Settlement

By January 2015, follow-up reporting said CHP had completed its investigation and attributed the collision to unsafe operation by the Alhambra fire truck. Even with that finding, no criminal charges were filed. That distinction is common in serious collision cases: a government agency can identify unsafe driving without prosecutors bringing a criminal case.

Civil claims moved on a separate track. Within weeks of the crash, Pasadena Star-News reported at least five claims against Monterey Park, with allegations including an amputated leg, blunt-force trauma, spinal injuries, and psychological harm. Later reporting said 22 claims had been filed in each city, though one had been dropped.

In July 2015, Pasadena Star-News reported that Thai was poised to receive a $15 million settlement funded by Alhambra, Monterey Park, and their insurers, without an admission of fault. The article said the payout would be made in installments and that the case would also affect the cities’ insurance costs for years. That settlement is one of the clearest signs of how devastating the crash was long after the sirens stopped.

Why Cases Like This Get Legally Complicated Fast

Emergency vehicles do receive special privileges in some situations, but those privileges are not unlimited. Drivers still have to operate with due regard for public safety. When a fire truck enters an intersection against a red light, strikes another emergency vehicle, injures pedestrians, and crashes into a business, the legal analysis can involve government claim deadlines, comparative fault arguments, eyewitness accounts, apparatus data, training records, and municipal insurance coverage.

Context Stats From the Reporting Trail

15 Injured
Later reporting counted four pedestrians, five restaurant patrons, and six firefighters hurt in the collision and building strike.
Los Angeles Times, ABC7, Pasadena Star-News
$15 Million
Pedestrian Kenneth Thai’s reported settlement showed the scale of the life-changing injuries tied to the crash.
Pasadena Star-News, July 2015
22 Claims in Each City
Follow-up reporting said a large number of claims were ultimately filed against Monterey Park and Alhambra, underscoring how one intersection collision rippled across civilians, firefighters, and public agencies.
Pasadena Star-News settlement coverage

Frequently Asked Questions

What did investigators later conclude caused the Monterey Park fire truck crash?
Follow-up reporting on the CHP investigation said the Alhambra fire truck entered the intersection against a red light and failed to make sure it was safe before proceeding. The Monterey Park engine reportedly had the green light.
Were criminal charges filed after the two fire trucks collided?
No. ABC7 reported that no criminal charges were filed after the yearlong investigation, even though CHP attributed fault to unsafe operation by the Alhambra truck.
Was there civil litigation after the restaurant crash?
Yes. Early reporting said multiple claims were filed soon after the crash, and later reports said Kenneth Thai, the pedestrian who lost his right leg, was set to receive a $15 million settlement funded by the two cities and their insurers.
Can people injured by an emergency vehicle still bring an injury claim?
Often yes, but those cases can be more technical than standard traffic collisions. Claims involving government vehicles may require early notice, fast filing deadlines, and careful investigation into whether the driver acted with due regard for public safety.

When an Emergency Response Crash Leaves Civilians With Life-Changing Injuries, the Legal Questions Do Not End at the Scene.

Cases involving fire trucks, city liability, catastrophic pedestrian injuries, and public-entity claim deadlines can get complicated fast. If you or your family were hurt in a serious California crash, Scranton Law Firm can help you understand the next step.

Free Case Evaluation

100% Confidential ยท No fees unless we win